In the Reddit post titled “Tone up sunscreens don’t have as much coverage, tanning, burns…?“, author throwawayhaha1101 opened up a conversation on the perceived lack of coverage offered by tone-up sunscreens. The user expressed frustration, noting that despite using broad-spectrum UVF 50+ PA++++ tone-up sunscreens, they seemed to experience more tanning and burns compared to regular sunscreens.
Several users chimed in to share their experiences and solutions. One insightful comment from circusmystery pointed out that the challenge with tone-up or tinted sunscreens often lies in the application. According to the user, people tend to apply less of it because a thick layer can create an exaggerated white cast or dark tint, which counteracts the sun-protective benefits. They suggested using a separate regular sunscreen underneath and then applying the tone-up sunscreen as a top layer for aesthetic correction.
Other comments echoed this sentiment. Another user, azdoroth, advised using a regular sunscreen with a tone-up cream on top, which helps in maintaining the required coverage while still achieving the desired brightening effect. Meanwhile, Eastern_Turnover_710 also shared a similar routine, underlining the importance of layering sunscreen to ensure adequate protection.
Diving deeper into the advantages and criticisms of tone-up sunscreens, a quick search yielded significant insights. For instance, tinted sunscreens are known for their dual function. According to a Harvard publication, such sunscreens offer broad-spectrum UV protection using mineral-based ingredients and iron oxides. Not only do they help to protect against UVA and UVB, but they are particularly effective at blocking visible light, including blue light from device screens, which can penetrate deeper into the skin and exacerbate conditions like melasma.
An additional review by ChristinaHello on the Cosrx Aloe 54.2 aqua tone-up sunscreen, highlighted the product’s SPF 50+ PA++++ rating along with its lightweight, fast-absorbing formula that offers both high UV protection and a subtle brightening effect. This product is particularly appealing for those looking for a natural, non-greasy makeup-free look.
In another related Reddit thread titled “what sunscreens broke you out? which didn’t?“, user Eatgslpg emphasized that while tone-up sunscreens are often considered good for sensitive skin, their experience with mineral sunscreens was disappointing as they experienced breakouts. This highlights that not all tone-up sunscreens are suitable for everyone and a patch test or consultation with a dermatologist might be prudent.
Overall, the community’s consensus indicates that while tone-up sunscreens offer additional cosmetic benefits, they may not always provide the same level of protection as traditional sunscreens unless adequately layered. As songdoremi aptly noted, formulations can vary significantly, making it essential to find the right product and application method tailored to one’s skin type and lifestyle needs.